U.S. Soy Survey Shows Shifts in Soybean Meal Valuation, Summer Swine Diets

Large Animal & Livestock

Survey of 2.1 Million Sows Tracks Soybean Meal Shift in Swine Diets

A U.S. Soy survey of 22 nutritionists covering 2.1 million sows finds 90% cut DDGS in summer diets and 77% now value soybean meal at 90%+ of corn's energy.

Photo: tomwieden / pixabay

Ninety percent of swine nutritionists surveyed by U.S. Soy have cut distillers dried grains with solubles (DDGS) from spring and summer diets over the past 24 months, a feeding shift aimed squarely at the seasonal summer carcass weight dip that costs producers marketable pounds when hog prices peak.

The Soybean Meal Swine Utilization Survey, released from St. Louis, measured whether two research-backed concepts have moved from journal pages into commercial feed formulation: higher net energy values for soybean meal relative to corn, and the use of inclusion-rate adjustments as a tool against seasonal carcass weight losses.

"The survey provides a benchmark to determine whether research findings are translating into commercial feeding practices, and the results are both positive and impressive," said Keenan McRoberts, Ph.D., executive vice president of strategy for the United Soybean Board. "I say impressive based on the speed of adoption and implementation that both concepts are being incorporated into commercial swine nutrition programs."

Who answered the survey?

The quantitative survey went out by email to 35 swine nutritionists. Twenty-two responded, representing operations with a combined 2.1 million sows. Fifteen respondents work as nutritionists on staff with swine operations; seven serve as nutrition advisors. Together they span commercial pork production companies, nutrition companies, consulting organizations and academic institutions.

The questionnaire asked two things: how nutritionists currently value soybean meal energy, and whether they modified DDGS and soybean meal inclusion rates during spring and summer.

How high do energy values now run?

Seventy-seven percent of respondents assign soybean meal a net energy value of 90% or greater than corn. That figure matters at the mixing truck. U.S. Soy's value proposition places soybean meal's productive energy at 97% to 105% of corn's net energy value. Nutritionists who value that energy accurately can formulate more economical diets, lowering feed costs while holding animal performance steady.

Adoption has moved fast. A benchmark that once lived mostly in research settings now governs how most surveyed operations price a major ingredient.

What changed in summer DDGS levels?

Over the last 24 months, 90% of respondents lowered DDGS inclusion in spring and summer diets, while 9% had not. Among those who cut DDGS, 85% reduced inclusion by 25 percentage points or greater. Two of three respondents who chose "Other" removed DDGS from late-finishing diets entirely.

"This feeding strategy is connected to efforts to manage the summer carcass weight dip," said Bart Borg, Ph.D., vice president of feed and nutrition at Passel Farms and a member of the U.S. Soy Swine Advisory Team. "By feeding higher levels of soybean meal while reducing DDGS, producers can minimize the predictable summer carcass weight decline, allowing producers to market more pounds when seasonal hog prices are typically at their highest."

Respondents linked the DDGS changes to improved carcass weight gain, feed conversion (F:G), average daily gain (ADG) and overall profitability.

How did soybean meal respond?

The DDGS cuts did not happen in isolation. Almost 60% of respondents increased soybean meal inclusion in late-finishing diets during the previous 24 months to blunt the summer weight dip; about 41% had not made that adjustment.

The size of the increases varied:

  • 38% raised soybean meal inclusion by less than 25 percentage points
  • Another 38% raised it by 25 to 49 percentage points
  • About 15% reported increases of 50 to 75 percentage points

Those who increased soybean meal reported gains in ADG and gain-to-feed ratio, plus improved cost per pound of gain.

What are the three headline numbers?

The survey condensed its findings into three shifts now visible in commercial barns:

  • 77% of nutritionists assign soybean meal a net energy value of at least 90% of corn
  • 91% have reduced DDGS use, and 85% of those cut inclusion by at least 25 percentage points
  • Almost 60% have raised soybean meal in late-finishing diets, with more than half of those increasing inclusion by at least 25 percentage points

Taken together, the results show how swine nutritionists are currently pricing soybean meal and reworking ingredient inclusion as they balance feed economics, pig performance and the seasonal carcass weight dip.

U.S. Soy plans to repeat the exercise. "We want to continue generating evidence with academic and commercial partners and allow nutritionists to determine how that research best fits their operations," McRoberts said. "We do plan to make this an annual survey to track U.S. soy use."

The project was fully funded by the Soy Checkoff, and full survey results are available through the U.S. Soy Center for Animal Nutrition and Health.

Source: morningagclips.com

Share this article:

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Small- and large-animal clinical practice at The Vet Scope.

More from Grace Kim →